First of all, why are homemade pies so good?! Ugh. They’re so good. They just hit right every time. That warm, bubbling filling, the flaky crust, and the old school, comforting feeling you get from a slice is unrivaled.
This Christmas, instead of serving a store bought pie, why not make your own? These 25 recipes aren’t just stunning to look at, they’re jam packed with flavors and easy as pie.
1. Buckeye Pie
Chocolate and peanut butter? Yes, please. This is pretty much a dream combo.
I’m just telling you now, you should probably plan on making two of this pie, because it’s going to be gone in a flash. The combination of rich chocolate with sweet and salty peanut butter is just completely irresistible.
The filling is so unbelievably good that the crust is whatever you want it to be. Store-bought, pre-baked, or made from scratch, it will be fantastic.
2. Eggnog Pie
Do you love eggnog? Okay, yes. Welcome. This pie is a total must-try for you.
We all know eggnog is a holiday staple, but why not kick it up a notch? Let’s turn that classic drink into a pie that will make everyone happy.
You get thick, creamy eggnog tucked onto a sweet, buttery graham cracker crust. A little nutmeg and cinnamon finish it off. This is the ultimate holiday dessert.
And (bonus!) there’s no major effort needed here. It’s so simple. You don’t even bake it! Seriously, just pour the eggnog mix into the crust and pop it in the freezer.
3. Chocolate Brownie Pie
Can’t pick between a brownie and a pie? Well, good news. You don’t have to.
Brownies are amazing all by themselves, obviously. But this chocolate brownie pie? It’s next-level.
It combines two classics into one, and it’s a total fan favorite. That flaky crust gets filled with a sinful brownie batter and is just loaded with chocolate chips.
It’s a completely fool-proof recipe to make your Christmas celebration even merrier and brighter.
4. Lemon Meringue Pie
This one is such a holiday classic, and it just never lets you down.
You’ve got a sweet, tangy, and velvety custard inside a crisp and buttery pastry crust. And the whole thing is topped with piles of fluffy meringue.
It’s perfectly sweet with a mild tang, and it’s 100% refreshing. That bright yellow filling is like a little bite of sunshine. And that golden-brown toasted meringue on top? Stunning.
5. Candy Cane Pie
A candy cane is pretty much the most Christmas-y candy, so this pie just makes sense for the holidays!
This peppermint pie is a guaranteed crowd-pleaser. I mean, how could anyone resist? It has an Oreo crust, a sweet cream cheese filling, and a topping of crushed peppermint.
What a wonderful explosion of flavors and textures. It’s a fun new spin on a classic cheesecake, and I am SO in.
Oh, and did I mention this pie needs zero baking? Yep, you don’t need to be a pro baker to nail this one. So easy.
6. Rum Raisin Apple Pie
This one simple addition completely transforms the classic apple pie into something so classy and heavenly.
The spiked raisins give the apple pie this beautiful contrast of texture and flavor. You get crisp, chewy, sweet, and a little bit of mild bitterness all in one bite.
That just sounds like absolute heaven to me.
7. Salted Caramel Pie
That drool-worthy combination of sweet and salty makes this pie totally impossible to resist.
Want your dessert to be a definite showstopper? Just drizzle it with salted caramel. It’s my go-to strategy, and it always works. Case in point: this salted caramel pie.
There is just no way you can say no to this. It brings together the goodness of chocolate, caramel, and sea salt to make one spectacular confection. So many decadent flavors in just one pie.
The Oreo pie crust adds another layer of sweet and buttery flavors, giving you one heavenly treat.
8. Dulce de Leche Pie
Rich cream cheese and ooey-gooey dulce de leche are tucked into a buttery Oreo crust. I think I just died and went to heaven.
The combination of thick caramel and cream cheese makes for the most well-balanced filling.
It’s sweet, but not *too* sweet, and has just a hint of tartness. This pie is simple, but wow, it really hits the spot.
9. Best Black Forest Pie
This is the most dreamy and decadent black forest cake, but in pie form. Just when I thought black forest cake couldn’t get any better, I tried this.
It’s made with fudgy chocolate, sweet cherries, and fluffy whipped cream, all in a flaky crust. Help! My self-control is gone.
10. German Chocolate Pie
This German chocolate pie is a total dream for chocolate lovers. Think of it as a hybrid of a German chocolate brownie and a chocolate pie.
It’s a rich, chewy, and ooey-gooey filling loaded with toasted pecans and chocolate, all in a golden crust. I mean, what more could you ask for?
Here’s a fun little tidbit: German chocolate cake actually has zero German roots. It was created by an American chocolate maker named Samuel German. So don’t let the name fool you. This dessert is 100% American.
11. Pecan Pie
Okay, if you’re searching for that perfect pecan pie, just stop. This is the one.
We’re talking a crisp crust, a super ooey-gooey filling, and a toasty pecan topping that is just heavenly.
It’s kind of amazing how a simple mix of sugar, salt, cinnamon, and vanilla can make such deep flavors that go so perfectly with the pecans.
And the crust? It’s the flakiest, most buttery crust ever. I’m not exaggerating. If you’re going to make a pie, making the crust from scratch is an extra step, but trust me, it is 100% worth it.
12. Cranberry Pear Pie
Sweet pears and tart cranberries? Yes. They come together to make this completely irresistible fruity pie.
There’s just something so amazing about that sweet and tangy combination. It’s the ultimate refreshing flavor! That’s why pears and cranberries just work so well together.
With the addition of cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice, this pie isn’t just sweet and tart; it’s also perfectly spiced. How cozy and warm is that?
Serve this cranberry pear pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and you’ll bring even more Christmas cheer.
13. Rocky Road Pie
If rocky road is your favorite ice cream flavor, you are going to love this pie.
Cocoa powder, cream cheese, and melted chocolate get mixed together to create a super-smooth, rich, and decadent filling.
The graham cracker crust adds a great crisp and buttery contrast to all that sinful chocolate.
It’s covered generously with mini marshmallows and almonds. This rocky road pie will take you to a place of eternal bliss.
14. Treacle Tart
Ever wonder why “treacle tart” sounds so familiar? If you’ve read the Harry Potter books, you’ll know it’s Harry’s favorite dessert!
Treacle tart is a traditional British dessert that’s often served during tea time. It has a buttery shortbread crust and a filling flavored with lemon.
The base of the filling is made from lemon zest, breadcrumbs, and treacle, which is how it gets its name.
Treacle is just a sweet, golden syrup made with sugar, water, and citric acid. When all those ingredients are combined and cooked, they create this thick, buttery, and caramel-y mixture. Yum.
15. Mincemeat Pie
Mincemeat or mince pie is a savory pie from across the pond. It’s a traditional British pie served up during the holidays.
The buttery and flaky crust is filled with a mix of dried fruits and spices, then baked until it’s golden perfection. I would gladly eat this pie even when it’s not Christmas.
Fun fact: mince pie goes all the way back to the 13th century, to the time of the Crusaders. They were originally called Christmas pies and were shaped into ovals to represent the manger Jesus was born in. A little depiction of baby Jesus was also placed on top.
The filling was a combination of mixed meats, fruits, and spices, representing the gifts from the three Magi. Centuries later, the pies are now smaller, rounder, and sweeter.
16. Snickerdoodle Pie
Snickerdoodle pie is just as fun to eat as it is to say.
Is it a cookie? A cake? A pie? Honestly, it doesn’t matter! All you need to know is that it’s outrageously delicious.
It’s a super soft and buttery snickerdoodle cookie topped with a sweet syrup, cinnamon, and a cream cheese glaze. This is basically Christmas in a pie!
17. Coffee Pie
Your favorite coffee flavors are infused into this smooth and creamy pie. This coffee pie is the perfect way to start your day.
It’s rich, creamy, and loaded with just the right amount of coffee flavor. It tastes amazing and smells like heaven, too.
The crust is also sublime. For me, when you have a smooth and creamy filling, you just can’t go wrong with a rich and buttery crust. Sure, graham cracker is great, but crushed Oreo cookies are even better. That rich chocolatey flavor just works so incredibly well with coffee.
18. Plum Pie
Sweet red plums are flavored with cinnamon inside this crisp, buttery pie. It’s such a simple recipe, but it delivers truly stunning flavors.
The cinnamon, sugar, and plums create this beautiful harmony of flavors. The rich and buttery crust is the perfect vessel to hold that crisp and syrupy filling.
19. Macadamia Coconut Tart
Give your pecan pie a tropical twist! This macadamia coconut tart is ridiculously rich, buttery, and just downright addictive. One spoonful will whisk you away to the tropics.
If you’ve never tried macadamia nuts and coconuts together, now is the time. This pie is a total dream for anyone with a sweet tooth.
A crisp and flaky golden crust is filled with a mixture of brown sugar, butter, vanilla, macadamia, and flaked coconut. That nutty, chewy filling tastes insanely delicious with the buttery crust. It’s so delightful.
20. Coconut Macaroon Pie
Let’s give Christmas a tropical flair with this decadent coconut macaroon pie.
Coconut macaroons are those rich and buttery little bite-sized snacks flavored with shredded coconut. Now, just imagine all that goodness in a pie form. That’s what this dessert is all about.
It has a flaky crust and a rich custard filling that is loaded with sweet coconut flavor. The coconut gets toasted while it bakes, which gives it a crisp texture and a much deeper flavor.
Plus, this pie couldn’t be easier to make. The filling comes together in just one bowl, and you don’t even need to make the crust from scratch.
21. Dutch Pear & Nutmeg Pie
Sweet, juicy, and perfectly spiced pears are baked in a fresh pie.
Just the thought of eating this pie while I’m curled up on the couch in front of a fire is giving me so much joy.
Dutch pears and nutmeg together create such warm, cozy autumn flavors. Add a soft and flaky crust to the whole situation, and you’ve got one heck of a comforting pie!
22. Hazelnut Pie
Attention all Nutella lovers: this pie is for you. Cream cheese and Nutella come together to make one insanely rich, creamy, and nutty pie.
The combination of hazelnut and cream cheese creates such bold and mind-blowing flavors!
And here’s the best part: it’s a no-bake pie! Hurray for hassle-free recipes! All you need to do is stir together softened cream cheese, Nutella, and powdered sugar, and your filling is done.
Don’t you just wish all desserts were this easy and this full of flavor?
23. Turtle Pie
Turtle pie is a classic dessert that’s packed with amazing flavors and textures that just work. It’s so good, one slice is not going to be enough.
This pie has a buttery graham cracker crust with a creamy filling, and it’s topped with pecans, chocolate sauce, and caramel. Just imagine all those flavors in one bite. So sinfully delightful!
It’s such a simple pie, too. Since you’ll be using a graham cracker crust, no baking is required. The filling only calls for cream cheese, powdered sugar, whipped cream, and chocolate spread.
Once you have all the elements ready, all that’s left is to assemble and chill. It couldn’t get any easier than that.
24. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie
This fruity pie combines all the goodness of cranberries and oranges. It’s the most refreshing pie, and it’s guaranteed to put a smile on your face.
It’s got a buttery crust filled with a sweet and tangy custard. The orange zest and cranberries make this pie extra bright and tangy!
Plus, just look at how gorgeous this pie is. That red hue from the cranberries makes it absolutely perfect for the holidays.