Old fashioned sweets carry a special kind of magic. These 19 retro Amish desserts offer a delicious blast from the past for your entire family.
Most of these treats rely heavily on butter for that signature melt in your mouth texture. Get ready for a tasty trip through Amish country.
1. Amish Oatmeal Cookies
Even people who dislike oatmeal usually adore these treats. They ditch the typical crunchy texture for a soft and chewy bite.
Peanut butter plus chocolate chips make them even better. You might just find a new top choice for your cookie jar.
2. Amish Apple Goodie
Modern cooks usually call this dish an apple crisp. Sliced apples swim in a syrup made of cinnamon and sugar beneath an oatmeal streusel topping.
The result is a buttery exterior hiding a tender interior. I love that you can mix everything in a single bowl for easy cleanup.
3. Pennsylvania Dutch Chocolate Funny Cake
This confusingly delicious treat combines elements of pie and cake. You get three distinct layers including a bottom crust and a chocolate center.
A moist cake layer sits on top. It looks complex but comes together quite easily.
4. Amish Gingerbread Cookies
I never cared for gingerbread until I tasted this specific version. Most childhood versions are tough but these stay moist and buttery.
The spice level is gentle rather than overpowering. You can dress up the little men any way you like.
5. Amish Cake
Start your day or end your meal with this incredibly moist creation. A topping of brown sugar and nut crumble makes it stand out.
While it counts as a dessert, I find it pairs perfectly with morning coffee. The batter relies on plenty of butter to delight your tastebuds.
6. Lemon Sponge Pie
Enjoy a light texture with this airy pie. It balances sweet and tart flavors without being overwhelming.
A creamy filling sits atop a buttery crust. A thin layer of sponge cake forms on the surface for a refreshing finish.
7. Amish Date Pudding
Even date skeptics often fall for this buttery dessert. It has a soft texture that feels incredibly delightful.
A brown sugar sauce drizzle and whipped cream top it off nicely. Try adding a scoop of ice cream to make it extra special for summer.
8. Amish Friendship Chocolate Muffins
Use your starter dough to bake these fluffy treats. They offer a rich cocoa flavor and a moist crumb.
You will want to eat them for breakfast or snacks all day. This recipe is a perfect solution for that leftover starter sitting on your counter.
9. Amish Apple Dumplings
Homemade dough wraps around crisp apples in this stunning fall dessert. A syrup made from brown sugar and cinnamon surrounds the baking dumplings.
I adore the flaky crust on these treats. The aroma alone is absolutely heavenly.
10. Church Window Cookies
The name sounds intriguing and the taste hooks you immediately. These no bake sweets feature chocolate wrapping around colorful marshmallows.
Walnuts and coconut add extra texture to the mix. The multicolored marshmallow slices look like stained glass.
11. Pennsylvania Shoo Fly Cake
Cake lovers will prefer this over the traditional pie version. It stays super moist and very sweet.
Molasses gives the crumb a deep golden color. A brown sugar topping adds a nice textural contrast.
12. Amish Molasses Cookies
These simple looking rounds are deceptively addictive. Molasses ensures every bite remains chewy and moist.
The buttery sweetness makes them hard to resist. They are also incredibly easy to bake when cravings strike.
13. Amish Pumpkin Pie Cake
It does not matter if you call it pie or cake because the taste is incredible. Layers of pecans and pumpkin filling sit between buttery cake.
You do not even need to mix a batter. Just sprinkle cake mix over the top before baking.
14. Amish Cinnamon Bread
Skip the labor of rolling dough and make this quick bread instead. It satisfies cravings for gooey cinnamon rolls without the yeast or kneading.
The texture remains fluffy and soft. People might think you spent hours in the kitchen.
15. Pennsylvania Dutch Potato Doughnuts
Using mashed spuds in the batter makes these treats incredibly tender. They look standard but the texture is exceptional.
A simple glaze and some sprinkles finish them off. I highly recommend trying this unique method today.
16. Amish Apple Fritter Bread
This loaf bursts with fruit and a cinnamon sugar topping. The interior stays fluffy while the crust gets crunchy.
No yeast means no kneading is required. It combines great textures without the long wait.
17. Chocolate Chip Amish Sugar Cookies
Standard sugar cookies get an upgrade with chocolate morsels. You get a buttery base studded with sweet chips.
This recipe offers the best of two classic desserts. Why choose just one when you can merge them?
18. Shoofly Pie
The name sounds funny but the taste is serious business. Molasses creates an ooey gooey filling that is wonderfully chewy.
A crumbly topping pairs with the flaky crust. The title actually comes from a brand of molasses.
19. Amish Oatmeal Pie
Kids who hate breakfast oats will still devour this sweet slice. A buttery crust holds a chewy brown sugar filling.
It tastes remarkably similar to pecan pie. The recipe originated when nuts were scarce during the Civil War.